Psychologists often disagree on confidentiality breaches

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Psychologists often disagree on confidentiality breaches

Although current guidelines regarding confidentiality within psychological practice are internationally consistent, many Australian psychologists still disagree on when they would breach confidentiality when dealing with adolescents, a new study by Murdoch Childrens Research Institute and Swinburne University of Technology has found.

Researchers asked over 260 psychologists about whether they would breach confidentiality with an adolescent client to disclose information about risk behaviour to their parents across 68 different scenarios. The scenarios covered six domains of risk behaviour, including smoking, drinking, sexual behaviour, drug taking, suicide and stealing, and varied in intensity, frequency and duration.

The study showed that, while they reached consensus in the most high-risk and low-risk scenarios, in 43% of cases, the psychologists failed to agree about whether a breach of confidentiality was necessary. The tendency to breach confidentiality increased across all six behavioural domains as the frequency, intensity and duration increased.

The highest level of consensus reached was 96%, who agreed that a parent should be informed following an admission of a suicide attempt more than once in the last month. Psychologists also agreed about not breaching confidentiality on a range of low-risk behaviours such as smoking cigarettes and engaging in sex with a steady girlfriend, as well as a range of higher risk behaviours at low intensities, such as engaging in illicit drug use once several months ago or binge drinking once a month for several months.

“It seems Australian psychologists are interpreting guidelines about confidentiality in very different ways. The Code of Ethics, written by the Australian Psychological Society, is clear, but making decisions on a case-by-case basis is complex. ‘An immediate and specified risk of harm’ might mean different things to different psychologists,” lead researcher, Dr Rony Duncan said.

“Given that psychologists vary in their practice, the findings also highlight the importance of psychologists maintaining principles of transparency and informed consent through communication about their limits to confidentiality.”

Researchers said the findings indicated that an extensive number of considerations are taken into account when making decisions about confidentiality, including how parents will respond if told about the risk behaviour, the adolescent’s maturity and the protective factors present in the adolescent’s life.

Circumstances in which participants demonstrated more than 80% consensus that confidentiality should be breached to inform parents
Risk behaviourLevel of frequency / duration% who would breach confidentiality
Engaging in unprotected sex while HIV+Monthly for several months87
Weekly for several months88
Nearly daily for the last year89
Using amphetaminesNearly daily for the last year80
Using inhalantsNearly daily for the last year83
Using hallucinogensNearly daily for the last year82
Suicidal ideation (“I wish I was dead”)Nearly daily for the last year85
Suicide gesture (taking pills)Once during the last month87
More than once during last month94
Suicide attemptOnce during the last month93
More than once during last month96


Circumstances in which participants demonstrated more than 80% consensus that confidentiality should not be breached to inform parents
Risk behaviourLevel of frequency / duration% who would breach confidentiality
Smoking cigaretteOnce several months ago97
Nearly daily for the last year92
Engaging in sex with multiple partnersOnce several months ago94
Monthly for several months91
Binge drinkingOnce several months ago98
Monthly for several months82
Stealing clothing from a storeOnce several months ago95
Once during the last month87
Stealing a car for a joyride with friendsOnce over a year ago83


Source: Murdoch Childrens Research Institute 

Date Created: February 4, 2013

Related Posts


Join our FREE monthly Newsletter!

Simply enter your email and first name below:

Parenthub respects your privacy. You can unsubscribe from the newsletter at any time.
Please read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.